Refining Successful Implementation Strategies for the Surgical Safety Checklist in High-Income Contexts: Results of an International Mixed Methods Study

The WHO Surgical Safety Checklist (SSC) continues to show inconsistent success in reducing surgical complications in high-income settings. Previous implementation research identified potential barriers and facilitators to success, but it primarily consists of qualitative studies with small sample sizes in limited geographic areas. We conducted a multi-country mixed-methods study of barriers and facilitators to SSC implementation to better inform policies and practices for improving SSC buy-in and use to maximize its impact. This convergent parallel mixed-methods study utilized survey and interview data from surgical team members practicing in five countries. Survey data were analyzed using χ2 analysis or Fisher’s exact test for categorical variables and McNemar’s test to analyze differences between related groups for dichotomous variables. Interview data underwent inductive coding followed by thematic analysis for predominant themes common across the study countries. The study resulted in 2,032 survey responses and 51 interviews. Facilitators to success included having influential multi-disciplinary champions from surgery, anesthesiology, and nursing; using a distributed leadership process to promote ownership across all surgical team members; and providing education on the “why” of the checklist. Practitioners found patient safety metrics (e.g., wrong side surgery) more relevant than clinical outcome measures (e.g., surgical mortality) to assess SSC success. Finally, auditing for process engagement was felt to promote more meaningful use than auditing for checklist completion. Our international examination of barriers and facilitators to successful SSC implementation has identified more specific guidance for high-income settings that integrate people, data, and processes.
Related content
-
Patient Family & Community Engagement | Quality & Clinical Excellence
What Healthcare Providers Need to Know About Newcomer Health Equity
Newcomers are a vital yet often misunderstood segment of the population that healthcare providers serve. This webinar explores the landscape of newcomer health equity in Canada and the United States, offering valuable insights into the challenges faced by this vulnerable group. Attendees will gain a deeper understanding of the various categories of newcomers in each
Learn more -
Innovation & Technology | Quality & Clinical Excellence
Improving The Patient Experience by Adopting a Culture of Safety
Discover the diverse landscapes of safety cultures across hospitals of varying sizes and explore the challenges that often impede their maintenance. Uncover effective solutions tailored to address these challenges, equipping hospitals with strategies to sustain and grow a robust culture of safety. Additionally, gain valuable insights into the present and future role of technology in
Learn more -
Quality & Clinical Excellence
Quality of Outpatient Care in Lebanon: A Cross-Sectional Survey
Patient experience is an important driver of healthcare improvement. Yet, in Lebanon, there is a lack of studies focusing on the satisfaction of outpatients with healthcare quality. This study aims to assess the quality of outpatient care in Lebanon from the patient’s perspective and identify its determinants. A cross-sectional survey was administered, between December 2023
Learn more