Correlation between Resident Physician and Patient Perceptions of Empathy in the Emergency Department
Published November 12, 2025
Background: Empathy is essential for emergency medicine physicians, impacting patient outcomes and experiences, especially in the fast-paced emergency department (ED). However, empathy often declines during medical training, negatively affecting care. Little is known about how emergency medicine trainees perceive their empathy compared to their patients. Objective: This study aimed to explore the correlation between patient perceptions of resident physician empathy and residents’ self-perceptions during ED visits. Methods: This was a prospective observational study was conducted at a Level 1 Trauma and Tertiary Care Center in the south-central U.S., using the Consultation and Relational Empathy (CARE) Measure. At patient disposition, ED patients rated their resident physician’s empathy, followed by residents rating their own empathy delivery. Ratings were categorized as high (>81%) or low (≤80%) empathy providers. The primary outcome was the correlation between patient and resident empathy ratings; secondary outcomes examined the effects of age, sex, and race. Results: Residents rated themselves as high empathy providers 32.6% of the time, while patients rated their residents as high empathy providers 68.5% of the time. Only 6% of interactions involved residents rating themselves as high empathy providers when patients did not. Older patients rated residents as low empathy providers slightly more often than younger patients. Differences in race and gender did not significantly impact empathy ratings. Conclusion: Our findings reveal a significant gap between resident physicians’ self-assessments of empathy and patients’ assessments, with residents often rating themselves lower than their patients did, highlighting a disconnect in self-perception among emergency medicine trainees.
Related content
-
Patient Family & Community Engagement
Turning Teen Volunteers into Healthcare Leaders
Published June 25, 2026
(This podcast is Part 1 of a content series on Teen/Youth Volunteer Programs.) What happens when hospitals stop treating teen volunteers as helpers and start empowering them as leaders? In this episode, Terri Ipsen sits down with Tracy Herrington and Tammy Rivera of CommonSpirit Health to explore an innovative teen volunteer program that develops leadership
Learn more -
Patient Family & Community Engagement
From Anticipation to Relief: Anxiety Reduction and Patient Experience as Indicators of Trust During Dental Extractions in Orthodontic Treatment
Published August 6, 2026
Trust is central to healthcare encounters involving fear and uncertainty. This quasi-experimental study evaluated changes in anxiety before and after dental extractions performed during orthodontic treatment planning and examined whether patient experience factors were associated with post-extraction anxiety. Fifty patients aged 11–40 years undergoing fixed orthodontic treatment requiring extraction were recruited consecutively at a tertiary
Learn more -
Patient Family & Community Engagement
A Dynamic Three-Stage Co-Design Process for Developing an Assessment Scale for Children with Neurodevelopmental Conditions
Published November 5, 2026
Background: Involving patient partners and diverse stakeholders in research is increasingly recognised as essential for aligning outcomes with patient priorities and improving service design. Co-design brings together individuals with lived experience, professional insights, and technical knowledge to improve research tools. Objective:This case study describes the process of co-designing a user-friendly assessment scale for children’s developmental
Learn more